Showing posts with label media. Show all posts
Showing posts with label media. Show all posts

Saturday, 27 April 2013

The Independent (Work Experience): Student Media and Leveson

This article was originally published by The Independent on Friday 22nd March 2013. Available here:
http://www.independent.co.uk/student/news/how-will-leveson-impact-student-journalism-8545630.html


At a City University debate this month, Neil Wallis, a former News of the World executive editor warned: "If there are any student journalists here: it’s your freedom and once it goes you won’t get it back." This advice strikes close to home for many students, as Leveson replicates an issue long-standing at university.

I joined The Yorker at university because the idea of the independent paper appealed to me over union-approved media. Our independence has stood firm since we launched; unlike the other major student papers on campus, we don't sign the YUSU charter and are not moderated. If campus papers adhere to union policies, then they are often subject to restrictions that leave many students without sufficient space for investigative journalism. Instead, papers become a mouthpiece of the authority figures as the university officials steer the direction of print.

You only need to look at recent censorship of student publications to see that Leveson is likely to compromise the young journalist position further. At Sheffield, The Forge Press was banned from distribution in halls after they broke a story concerning the exploitation of a pay loophole by the university. Elsewhere, in Leeds, the NUS attempted to prevent the publishing of an interview with infamous BNP leader, Nick Griffin. 

The most prolific example was probably in the case of Edinburgh University, whose student union served an interim interdict on the The Student paper after a story that could have potentially harmed their reputation was slated for front page. Instead, the students decided to leave the front page with the single word ‘Censored’, but it's still wrong that an article of such gravity should be restricted from student access, especially if rumours will circulate due to the injunction order. The truth and student journalist integrity would be better.

On Question Time last year, Guardian columnist Simon Jenkins warned the audience that: “Every single measure introduced by parliament to restrict your freedom always goes further, it never goes backwards.”
It seems that some student papers could essentially be double-restricted by the proposals, government adding to union restrictions. There is a sense of trepidation: just where should regulation end and student independence start?

At the very climax of years of hard work fine-tuning the ability to report a ground-breaking story, students’ first medium of expression is set to be stifled. How should upcoming reporters explore their journalistic potential if they cannot follow their leads and initiatives?

Ian Hislop, editor of Private Eye, participated in a candid interview about Leveson on the BBC this week: “People are saying there’s a certain amount if independence in there? Is there?” he questioned. “Independence or not independence? It tends to be a quality that’s either one or the other.”

This has been the issue for students for decades. The best stories came from publishing news the unions didn’t want in print, so undoubtedly the trouble is learning to compromise union policies with student rights. If Leveson meddles in a manner that the unions have advocated thus far, independence is really something under threat, and students may never know true journalistic freedom.


Tuesday, 1 May 2012

A Small Step for Internet Censorship


Earlier in the year, the internet came under attack from American government bills, with the infamous SOPA act to attempt to block and take down a number of sites believed to be infringing copyright laws. The result was a resounding victory for the public, who rallied support in order to save their most trusted and most visited websites.

Whilst a number of hosting services fell victim to pre-emptive attack on these streaming hosts, largely, the number of sites taken down was minimal and new domains have sprung up to plug the gaps left.

However, yesterday saw a new invasion into the internet’s freedom of ownership, speech and usage. High Courts in the UK ruled that major internet service providers had to block their subscribers from accessing file-sharing site The Pirate Bay. 

The Swedish based website has come under attack several times in the past, as it is currently one of the most recognised and most visited sites for sharing copyrighted medias. Indeed, back in 2009, Swedish courts ruled that the four founding members of the sites were guilty of helping people to circumvent copyright laws.

Despite this, the site has continued to thrive. Whilst the original founders are found responsible as being the powder-keg for this peer-to-peer service, the onus now rests with public demand.

Under the new laws, Sky, Everything Everywhere, TalkTalk, O2 and Virgin Media must all prevent their users from accessing the site. BT, meanwhile, has been asked for a further period in which to consider its position. Instantly, there is already fragmentation in how this act is to be carried out and monitored on a nationwide scale. Should even just one major provider fail to support the ban, then consumers with little conscious guilt about avoiding purchasing their music and video will simply switch provider.

Additionally, the idea of attacking The Pirate Bay alone is such a limited and naïve outlook from the British Courts. A wide network of these sites are active and removing the most popular offender will only provide the opportunity for another site to rise to prevalence. Consider the closure of the Limewire service, a group that were at one point synonymous with illegal file sharing.

Whilst I empathise with a wide selection of music and film industry persons who are losing money thanks to such services, there needs to be a greater understanding of the consumer demands. 99p for a single song on ITunes or Amazon does not provide great value for money. CD albums and movie releases, which have dropped in price considerably since the mid-90s as consequence of the sharing phenomenon, still need to be introduced to the consumer public at a cheaper price. Although such a suggestion may appear to damage these industries, if it would encourage and stimulate further legal purchases, then the overall effect could be to galvanise a higher gross income and reduce the popularity of these illegal services.

Yet, my own issue with the new court ruling is that which incited many to action back in February: the beginning of internet censorship could lead to a mass cull of websites and information deemed to be illegal or in need of restriction. Wikipedia, for example, is an online encyclopaedia database, where just a decade ago, people would have had to go to a library or purchase an almanac for such detailed results. Or even high street chains, put out of business by online giants such as Amazon. The array of services that could be deemed damaging to different groups are almost infinite.

Jim Killock, executive director of the Open Rights Group, called the move "pointless and dangerous". "It will fuel calls for further, wider and even more drastic calls for internet censorship of many kinds, from pornography to extremism," he said.

The popularity of the internet is based on its public orientation, built to offer information and services at the lowest price in the easiest way. File-sharing sites blocked in this haphazard fashion are only piecemeal solutions and at best, short-sighted. Where the demand and software is available, new services will entice the public with offers of free media.

With the advent of free services such as Youtube and Spotify for music, and free film channels on TV, the problem of piracy is none too clean cut. These were seen as things that may kill off their respective industries, but instead provided another outlet to reach an increased demographic. Some may want to watch or listen to material to be sure they want to buy it; others wouldn’t buy the product even without pirate sites. The pros and cons of these institutions are diverse, and whilst it is certainly morally indecent to essentially steal a film or song, perhaps it is also wrong to force the hands of the public in a free state, utilising a free domain.

Wednesday, 25 January 2012

World Wide Black Out

Firstly, readers should have some context as to SOPA and how support had grown before last Wednesday:


Last week’s ‘Black Wednesday’ movement across the internet in protest to the proposed PIPA and SOPA bills were undoubtedly a widespread victory.

Having previously held the backing of law-makers, large multi-national corporations and large swathes of US press, the action staged over a single day effectively U-turned the action and has displaced the probability of the legislation being passed over the coming years.

For one of the first times, web based action had a positive, constructive voice within US congress, with ripples felt around the world.


Effectively, the SOPA and PIPA acts would have allowed US firms that found content shared contrary to their distribution policy to take the websites to court and have the site blocked, causing investors to pull their contributions and slowly destroy the financial viability as well as the overall creditability of the site.

Nothing short of internet censorship.

What makes the internet such an effective and efficient communicative tool is the sheer volume of mediums by which an unprecedented number of media and information file types can be conveyed and shared. Never before has public information been so versatile: it is the voice of the public that shapes internet content itself.

In fact, the evidence of the PIPA and SOPA rejections has effectively ensured the twitter revolution continues, as a new frontier of global enfranchisement.

In the face of the prospect of what has been dubbed Black March, a month of protest against the bills, support has dwindled to a new low. The power of internet support has never before had such a widespread impact and has now proved itself an indicator of public feeling and mode on a range of issues, beyond the simple forms of protest staged by social utility websites.

An estimated 13 million people participating in Wednesday's online protest, with approximately 50,000 websites going dark during the day, most notably for a public domain, Wikipedia. Opponents additionally sent around 3 million email messages to Congress during the protest.

Of course, there is no denying the extent to which the internet unwittingly promotes piracy: in 1999, the RIAA sold $15billion of music on CD and tape formats. Even with the advent of easier download, that figure had more than halved to just under $7billion last year.

However, the internet allows much more music to be accessed on demand across more genres, from more eras and by more users. Perhaps the new measure of music success in a digital age is Youtube hits: Stand up Rihanna, making headlines this week being confirmed as the most viewed female artist on the video sharing site.

Diversifying and altering the means by which success becomes apparent is crucial in an era that has seen the integration of online players, streaming films, blogged news and social updates.

Besides, the more worrying problem is how easily such a bill may have been passed. Without the social media consensus, there probably would have been a blanket black out as websites were pulled left and right.

For example, in the dying days of the Labour government of 2010, just such a bill was passed in this country, but shifted to the bottom of the news pile amongst election propaganda. The ‘Digital Economy Bill’ made it legal for files to be brought to websites that ‘may be suspected of uploading copyright materials’ even if there was not yet proof of this activity.

It is time to realise that our own country has supported these draconian restrictions that inhibit the freedom of internet usage and that whilst digital territory, these are still the fringes of our rights to freedom of expression and should be guarded with stringent attention.

Otherwise, there may not be such a clear cut warning the next time such a bill faces a world government.

Sunday, 22 January 2012

"Statutory Regulation is not Required" - Leveson Inquiry Latest


Lord Justice Leveson’s inquiry into the media misconduct recommenced this month after the Christmas period to as much furore as had previously shrouded the case.

Over the past week, a number of official apologies have been issued to the victims of hacking from corporate giant News International. The statements released mark an interesting and significant development in the proceedings in the court examination, as the executive groups in charge of News International had held their ground in rebuking all the claims even till the latter stages of 2011.

Among those high profile figures who have now settled are actor Jude Law, politician Lord John Prescott and athlete Gavin Henson, alongside several other famous figures and ordinary persons alike.

It is hoped that with the admissions made by the firm, there may be some further ground covered as to how far the alleged transgressions had become common practice.

Of course, the revelation that emails were also targeted by many news groups has released fresh controversy that is not too difficult to imagine by any stretch of the imagination. Should these allegations prove true, it not only adds an extra dimension to the case, but ensures that there may need to be further sessions, divided by invasion category.

After all, Lord Leveson has made public his intention to release the first findings in September and the nine month period could easily be filled by thorough investigations of the initial claims.

In an inquiry whose costs are now expected to be in excess of £10m in compensation, it is the ethical value of the newspaper corporations that shall now be the method of payment for many of the firms. Open and transparent contributions are expected of all, and are anticipated as a form of apology, a form of exoneration, from many reporters and key figures.

When the story originally broke with the Guardian, one aspect that caused the most concern was the belief that executives, chiefs and editors at News Group Newspapers (NGN) were aware of the malpractice of their employees within the papers they printed.

With the eight week of the inquiry being proliferated with various editor figures from across the media domain, it was perhaps the comments of the Private Eye editor, Ian Hislop, which gained the most attention. In addition to proffering a different tone with his witty satire, he claimed that “statutory regulation is not required.”

In the face of the widespread controversy, such an outlandish statement appears insulting to the work of those leading the investigation, and to those whose privacy was invaded. However, Hislop developed his argument, citing that all the charges facing the accused relate to practices that are already illegal.

Instantly, Hislop has pointed out a crucial oversight of the public eye. Whilst there have been calls for tighter administration of the newspapers, this only invites government control, censorship, propaganda. The press is first and foremost a domain of free speech. By employing methods which impede on this right of print, the subsequent material cannot be expected to achieve the same insights, the same coverage, the same depth as has come to be expected of the British broadsheet.

Rather than focus on the produce of the paper, there need be a reformation of the central structures, ensuring that the sources of stories are trusted informants, open to public query at any junction. Perhaps this approach may result in fewer people offering information that may have some backlash, but in the interest of paper pride, this method of printed sources would align with a freedom of information that satisfies the public at large and permits media groups to remain insightful and current.

Yet, as a consumer conscience always craves the latest scandal, the irony of the media position was emphasised as Lucie Cave argued that the public had an interest in exposing hypocritical behaviour. The newspapers, once the source of scandal, now the subject of its wrath.

Saturday, 2 July 2011

Don’t Believe The Hype.


Free speech in Western democracies is a given to which we all adhere: foreign dictatorships send shudders down our spines. Looking out towards these places with limits on what it is permissible to vocalise, many question how those in power are able to defend their stance and how those who are forced into these submissive positions are able to live under such limitations. Gaging how far a country’s freedom of speech is impoverished is not a difficult task: often, one only has to look towards the medias that lie within. Normally, they will be heavily state controlled and censored by government and law. Frequently, they will portray positive images of the most controversial decisions and leaders. 

Media influence however has deemed it a reflex to assume that our system of freedom is instantly superior to that of those elsewhere. There are obvious reasons for this stance. We need only consider China’s banning any reference to or any shows and literatures pertaining to time travel in May as a case of the over-zealous manner in which some prohibitions are applied. Can we imagine their version of Doctor Who? On a more serious note however, the Chinese government labelled this a bid to increase national identity and pride: “Time travel shows are irresponsible in not respecting history” it was announced and the officials continued to describe time travelling shows as “frivolous” and a way by which “to re-write history”. Fair enough, the Chinese ministers wish to create an air of solidarity in what China has achieved in the past half a century, becoming the quickest emerging superpower, but surely more of this present can be appreciated if other realities were speculated at the same time? Just a thought.

Last year, North Korea banned World Cup games from live screening. Instead, matches where the national team won were only broadcast after the event itself. In the case of defeat, past winning scores were shown in some way to negate the loss in the current competition. The aim was to keep moral high. Such extravagance in control however is tantamount to abuse and insulting populus’ intelligence. The country’s residents are going to notice that the World Cup trophy didn’t arrive in Korea… even if the government can conceal it’s Spanish destination.

Of course, these governments promote their version of events as helpful in their controlling the country: indeed, China’s seemingly exponential growth in the past few decades now has it a country amongst the top traders, it boasts the first fully functioning maglev, the largest metro system in the world, has hosted the Olympics and is predicted to soon be putting out more academic research than the USA (academia now being a new measure of world power). Therefore maybe there is something to be said for the tightly run state: it seems to have fostered in all the people a dedication to a way of life that brings greater benefits if they are more in routine. Disturbingly, it appears on the surface as a rehash of the American Dream. 

Elsewhere, the power of the media is something to be feared. When free speech developed in Rwanda for example through the use of the radio, RTLM was amongst the first stations to be independent of the government. Upon its launch, it was proclaimed that:

We have a radio here, even a peasant who wants to say something can come, and we will give him the floor. Then, other peasants will be able to hear what peasants think. Personally, I think what complicates things is that ordinary citizens have no forum where they can speak. Normally, for ordinary citizens to speak, they speak through elections and elections are impossible. So, in fact, ordinary citizens have been deprived of a say but RTLM is there, we will give them the floor.
(Gaspard Gahigi, RTLM, 19 March 1994)

For those less illuminated with the facts, the radio station then went on in the following months to incite genocide that saw the deaths of almost 1 million Tutsis. The station broadcast names and locations of ‘traitors’, described those to be killed as subhuman and the action of murder as nothing but work. The extent of the damage is still visible today: once the months of bloodshed were over, government controlled radio was all that was permitted: all media remains heavily monitored today lest such unspeakable horrors should be repeated. And what was the world doing whilst these tragedies unfolded? The Western media was more concerned with the death of Kurt Cobain and the OJ Simpson case. Two men overshadowed a nation.

Priority of reporting then comes into question. Through our own negligence, we allow medias to dictate our perceptions of the world and what happens. No area should be left unbroached. Recently, this concern has grown closer to home. Whilst I am concerned for family well-being, the late super-injunction scandal brings entire reams of freedom of speech and freedom of the press into question. If we are unable to pass comment on these smaller matters, how soon before there are limits in place on other things of grand importance? To ban any comment is to undermine the very foundations of the current system of democracy held in the Western hemisphere. Whilst extending the principle to more serious matters could appear somewhat dramatic and far-fetched, conceding a small amount of rights has often led to great swathes of rights being attacked.

Therefore, we need consider the role of government and its interrelation with the media in a 21st century world. No doubt, technology has come to consume and dominate entire swaths of the planet with its ease of use and rapid transit of information. However in its misuse, there can be death, restraint and feeding ego of power heads of state. Moreover, a more broad perspective need be considered: restrictions elsewhere have contributed to shaping China and protecting Rwandans. Free speech in Western democracies is a given to which we all adhere: free speech in Western democracies is under attack, but is it advantageous?