Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Law. Show all posts

Sunday, 17 June 2012

Driving To The Brink


It’s probably a fair assumption that even in Britain there remains some low-level of gender discrimination, a mark of a bygone era of patriarchies. More often than not, this continues to manifest itself in various forms of slanderous remarks, wittingly made acceptable by terming it a joke. Perhaps most prevalent amongst these ‘joking’ insults is the seemingly innocent observation that “women drivers can’t drive”.

Yet, there are places where this same phrase is taken more literally: women in Saudi Arabia are actually banned from driving as part of the law. And a law that seems without any reason to support it, with the King of Saudi Arabia repeatedly professing that “there will come a time for the law to change.”

Women of the state appear to have gotten bored with the deliberation over when to lift the ban. Today, females staged a mass protest in its most demonstrative form: those that held an international licence were urged to get behind the wheel of a motor vehicle and drive.

Punishment for the offence is more sever than a Westerner might anticipate. Violaters are subject to a wide range of possible outcomes, from prison sentences to public lashings. More, these women are often subject to suffer the wider implications for their actions: they can lose their jobs, receive hate mail, threats online and lose their friends. Simply for taking control.

Imagine having to find a dependent to ferry you everywhere all the time. Not exactly the violation of human rights that is foregrounded by most, but a slight on freedom none the less.

Yet, I find myself wondering whether it is not a slightly hypocritical view for the West to suddenly be outraged by actions that these very countries condoned just 150 years ago (and even more recently). The ban reads to me as though a draconian, Victorian measure: and after all the Victorian era was the golden era of modern enlightenment. Perhaps this discrepancy in gender equality is something that each region and country must contend itself with in order to reach a cosmopolitan attitude.

Of course, the reasons to leave all laws as they are strike a reader immediately. Saudi Arabia is in the centre of a hot bed of political unrest and uncertainty. The Middle East has this past year ignited with uprisings and revolts that have marred the region with destruction and death. In a country that remains prosperous and with relatively low crime, there is no sense in disrupting the current politics in case it proffers the spark for wider social revolutions. Besides, a large enough proportion of the population seem so acceptant of the driving ban that their instant reaction is to shun those who make a stand.

Indeed, the powerful Shura Council have widely promoted a highly propaganda based study on the effect of women driving in society and claim that any licence for women to get behind the wheel is a full throttle approach to an increase in divorce, prostitution, drug abuse and child baring out of wedlock. How should the women make themselves heard against such controversial views?

A starting block would be ensuring the incoming choice to vote: 2015 set to be the year in which women are included in the voting system for the first time. King Abdullah, at 87, may not live to see such an event however, and there are worries that any possible successor may revoke the right.

The worry is that anarchy can come from the smallest of changes in one of the most volatile areas of the planet at the moment. Yet surely this fevour for activism is more likely should changes not present themselves as in the offing? It will only be a certain amount of time before neighbouring action causes enough friction to instigate action, and that would bring about the very scenario the government are trying to avoid.

Whilst Saudi Arabia is not a Western country, and does not want to be perceived as adhering to Western norms or culture, some lenience may be the only way to ensure a continued peace and stable state.

Tuesday, 4 October 2011

Murder, Mystery; Accused, Acquitted.


Yesterday Amanda Knox walked free of the controversial murder of a British student in Italy.

Four years ago, Leeds University student Meredith Kercher was found dead in her shared student flat in in Perugia, Italy, where she had been undertaking part of her course abroad. In the interim, various people have been brought before legal systems in the European state and each has been appealed amidst a growing media frenzy that now has a question mark poised above the case.

Acquitted after serving a number of years in jail, where it is rumoured that she was badly beaten and abused by both police and fellow inmates, Knox was yesterday delivered exoneration.

Addressing the gathered jurors and officiators before the verdict was heard, Knox pleaded that she was “not who they say I am” and that a combination of corrupt police evidence and media furore had painted an unfair image on her character. Also on trial, ex-boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito added that the ordeal was a “nightmare” from which he had never woken.

Court officials were put beyond reasonable doubt when the case was reviewed this year as the evidence that had been gathered for original sentencing was said to have a number of flaws.

Contamination claims were treated with severity and the courts requested further DNA tests to be undertaken after it was agreed that the original conditions fell short of international standards. Rumours included that the police had not adhered to protocol in reviewing the evidence.

Key in the case, a kitchen knife that had been put forward as having had Knox’s DNA on the handle, Kercher’s on the blade. In addition, the accused’s genes were found on the victim’s bra.

Enormous pressure has of course fallen on both defending and accusing parties over the course of the action. Statements from examining officials claim that a number of Knox’s statements in court go against those she gave in original writing. Meanwhile, the rebuttal argument stands that the police treatment and stress of a friend dying caused any discrepancy to occur.

Indeed, so much has the argument of foul-play been brought into the courtroom that earlier in the year, Knox’s own parents were summoned to an Italian court for vilifying the police.

Now as the pardoning comes as a relief to the “broken” jailed, it advocates a serious need for further regulations and review.

Sex game or murder? The case needs further scrutiny for sure.

Meredith Kercher was found by police with her throat slashed. However, initial investigations also revealed that there was proof of sexual activity before her death. Whilst the nature of the death remains a mystery then, there is an obvious need for prudence.

Should there have been any carnal relations, the very nature of evidence found on items such as the deceased’s bra is instantly rendered rather dubious. Moreover, although the knife in question may indeed have been the murder weapon per se, student is as student does. Ergo, the genetic evidence on the handle could easily be a case of poor, or complete lack thereof, cleaning utensils after usage.

In addition, should the act have been perpetrated in the midst of erotic activity, surely the idea of murder in the first degree pushes lawful boundaries? For instance, there is a lack of mens rea: stating that a vicious crime needs a vicious will. Concordantly, the Italian justice system should have only been in the process of manslaughter charges at the most. Murder undermines both the system and nature of the case.

Although two people walk free today, another, Rudy Guede, is still serving time for the crime. We must question how many were involved in the killing of a self-sufficient and innocent English student. It does not seem logical that so many should want her dead.

Evidence being inconclusive and logic failing the circumstances, there can be no alternative but to grant freedom to Knox under current conditions. In fact, as the judge ruled that there was "no evidence of Knox having ever committed murder", there should be some compensation in the offing to appease what is a life ruined: Knox graduates prison without a degree, without friends, and without imminent prospects.

Grieving relatives may still have to trawl through the agonising details; the broken accused has to rebuild from painstaking experiences.

Wednesday, 17 August 2011

To Punish or Not to Punish.


Certain incredulity is surely abound amongst the British population tonight as MPs argue back and forth over the level of punishment suitable for the rioters that ruled several important cities across the country last week.

Coming to terms with the extent of last week’s devastating loots, the Prime Minister, David Cameron, last week publically pledged that all those found to have been involved in the illicit actions would be met with the full force of the law: a sentiment that was supported by the vast majority of the nation. Mr Cameron added “If these people are old enough to commit the crime, they are old enough to face the punishment.”

However, as it emerged that some of the participants were as young as eight years old, there begs the question of the age of criminal responsibility. Moreover, this issue is one clearly within the public spotlight and mind frame. Unlike the daily sessions in court, specific interest has caused a commotion and tense atmosphere under which jurors are expected to pass harsher sentences than normal.

Of course, these are no normal conditions. Law should be considered as a measurable tool for each individual and not haphazardly applied in blanket fashion across all those who are not law abiding citizens.

Yet it is somewhat disparaging and deeply concerning when people are faced with this comparison: 18 year old, David Atto, pleaded guilty to the theft of two Burberry T-shirts. With no previous convictions against his name and an honest plea, he was sentenced to a day in custody. Meanwhile, Nicolas Robinson, 23, of Borough, south-east London, was jailed for six months for burglary. Of course, whilst the nature of the offense is similar to that above, Robinson took a £3.50 bottle of water from a Lidl Supermarket. The difference is astounding to say the least.

Some judges cite the difference of the level of crime as meriting the change in sentence strength. The natural response is an onslaught of appeals to what many feel constitute a miscarriage of justice. 

However, if the perpetrators were so moved to action in a frenzy trusting that they would only receive trivial punishment, then the system need not cave on the level of severity introduced thus far.

Now that more than 1,000 people have been sentenced in association with the disturbances, the murmurs of discontent on both sides are spreading. As changeable and extreme as the punishments first appear, ex-Lib Dem leader Sir Menzies Campbell has urged MPs not to pass comment. Any attempt by MPs to influence judges' decisions was "not consistent with the rule of law", he told the BBC. In a radio interview, he elaborated by explaining, “What I don't think is right is that politicians should have a league table in which they approve of some sentences and disapprove of others. It's none of our business.”

Unprecedented opinions however are sure to spill over and whilst Sir Campbell’s comments make sense so as not undermine any law system, these, the most powerful men and women in the country, are looked toward first and foremost from a populous so dumbfounded.

Technological twists only further tangle the trials and thought on relevant sentence. With many now being brought to court for Facebook and Twitter comments as inciting violence, there is a difficulty with how to justify any extended action if the person was not directly involved or foolishly made a passing jibe. In almost a sci-fi fashion, we could be advocating courts to follow through on pre-crime solutions. 

Level of justice and level of crime. Scales that constantly need be measured to ensure a smoothly running country have here seemed to see-saw back and forth. But as a public we must remember, we are no more qualified to say what is suitable punishment than the MPs. Politicians make law; police and courts enforce and implement law.