Showing posts with label av. Show all posts
Showing posts with label av. Show all posts

Monday, 9 May 2011

Checkmate becomes Stalemate

Previously, government politics has been assumed the same level as a game: not one of particular strategy, but a game of chance and foul-play against other party leaders. It would appear that following last Thursday’s election results, such an analogy holds firm and true. In a somewhat unprecedented move, Nick Clegg has spoken out against the Health Reform to the NHS that has been proposed by officials and had had backing of the Deputy Prime Minister until this week. The timing is rather too convenient to be attributed to coincidence. A stung Clegg is taking a stand in a bid to remind the Conservative coalition that its power is dependent, no matter how slight, on his backing. To play on the game analogy, stalemate.

When interviewed over the weekend, all questions towards the Lib Dem party pivoted on the huge losses signified by the local elections. Many people are now aware that the political group had its support essentially wiped out in Scotland and there were heavy losses across the majority of the country. Of course, the main hit was the rejection of the AV referendum: a change that Clegg had been championing for some time now.

Consequently, whilst gains were made by Labour in the North and the Conservatives held the swing of the previous national election, the Lib Dems have been considerably damaged. It should come as no surprise: in order to hang on to the coattails of power, they have formed a coalition that little reflects the promises of 2010 and so just as the party started to regain its previous prominence, faith in change has been wiped.

“Overall they got their lowest share of votes in three decades” claimed ‘The Guardian’ statistics. It has been almost a century since the predecessor of the current party held sway: the rise of Labour saw a much more approachable and thorough mode of socialism, that was not so centre ground. Being ‘stuck in the middle’ of the emergent political climate of the Conservatives and Labour made playing games quite a necessary move. For all the two large parties of the twentieth century would attack each other, the Liberals and subsequent Lib Dems would present themselves as the alternative, the balance, the measured view and pointed to any form of extremity to gain favourable opinion. Indeed it is probable that if AV had been in force for the last election, Liberal Democrats would now be in power.

However, in order to hold a prominent position, the Lib-Dems have taken U-Turns on a number of their pledges just twelve months ago. This is only to be expected: playing game earns reputation and power. Therefore, Clegg calculated stronger gains as a consequence. Unfortunately, the number of accessions granted to the Conservatives has seen negative growth of support.

Clegg’s claim to prevent the passing of the NHS Bill then may in part be founded on principle and there can be no doubt that there were some issues he had wanted to be addressed. What goes against such an argument in solid fact is that the Deputy PM has already signed the White Paper agreeing to the reform and the majority of his party had backed him. The BBC’s Deputy Political Editor, James Landale, suggests that “underlying it all is an identity crisis that these elections have forced on the Lib Dems”. That is to say that now the party has figures noting their overwhelming loss, they have to address the stem of the issue and return to Liberal politics. 

Calculated or adolescent the move may be, but Clegg pledges to now stay true to his claim. It certainly appears a rash and rather selfish move: since you’re making gains in one area, I am going to demonstrate how much power I have. Stalemate.

In this regard, whilst the Lib-Dem leader says that “where we achieve Liberal Democrat policies in government, we've got to tell people about it,” this quote should in itself not be taken as a sign of a stand, but more an awareness that the Liberal-Democrats have lost touch with their electorate and are now going to take advantage of all mediums possible in order to solidify and restart. The idea is that the people are key and so we shall highlight success and minimise failure. Once more, the constituency are treated without respect of knowledge that they deserve.

Whilst a Labour motion to prevent the bill continuing was today revoked (09/05/11), the movement highlighted the growing divide in the coalition government. If a general election was to be held and another coalition formed, the Lib Dems would again have scope to seek out a new route of choice. But rising unpopularity ensures that this government need remain in power until there has been a stopper put to the flailing support of party members and supporters alike. Declaration of vote timing is much more crucial and a matter of winning the public than previously, for it can enable a frame picture against other parties that solidifies position. Reforms that go wrong could ruin reputations.

“We've got to show people where we are a moderating voice on the Conservatives. We need to stand up for our values and say that loud and clear.”  A very noble sentiment indeed, but since it has taken twelve months for this idea to take a hold of the coalition minority party, political sway has again become a case of playing on the power and reputation that one can sacrifice in order to hopefully see gain in support. It may be said that the value of any political party is determined by how far it is able to undermine the others. Only when this is achieved in majority can there be an end to stalemate. Checkmate.

Wednesday, 4 May 2011

Fairer Votes? Just Give Us A Fairer Government!

Elections on the 5th May have generated a great deal of interest as they rightly should. Last year’s national election saw a hung parliament and  a consequent coalition has emerged: that twelve months later it has a united front is evidence of the dedication and commitment each party has made to compensate, compromise and collaborate with each other. Coalitions are indeed often considered weak and ineffective, but this government has so far tackled huge issues (which undoubtedly leave a lot of room for problems and grumbling) concerning education costs and public sector reforms. 

Now the promise of a referendum is delivered. Never in recent centuries has there been such a crucial opportunity to change our system of enfranchisement. As ever, every voter counts. Not only do recent polls demonstrate that opinion is spilt, swinging back and forth on the issues, but with fewer people actively interested in politics at large, this event has created an air of suspense between many. 

65.1% turned out in the elections of 2010 and this was considered a great achievement considering the previous election had only received 61.4% and prior to that 59.4%. However, we should consider that only as far back as 1997, there was a 71.4% turnout – and that was the lowest recorded figure in the post-World War Two era. No doubts can be held that there has been a significant drop in the number of voters – and yet there is greater concern about the way in which our government passes law. In this case, the first method by which to attain a fairer government appears fundamental: vote. With more than a third of the nation not helping to gage true feeling and beliefs, there is not the room for government to be considerate.

Yet, we may question the reasons behind the sudden drop. In a politically correct era, politics has become increasingly filled with jargon and specialist lexicon that prevent access and appreciation for the system. Moreover, with greater media outlets than ever before, parties have simply not campaigned as widely as they possibly could. People’s interests lie in so many different areas today that a government, especially one riddled with cynicism from any onlooker, needs to adapt to circumstance and target groups all through the term – not just at election time. There need be change effected for good, not for votes. Therefore, government need be more clear and defined and pro-active; so make them work for this.

Of course, the previous ideas of making politicians work all throughout their time in parliament sounds quite novel to many sceptics. However, the image serves to highlight how far politics has become a game. We only become actively involved as a society when elections are taking place. Whereas in decades gone by, social reforms, political movements and technological advances ensured politicians were seen every day to make comment and move people to belief, today politicians appear more competitive for votes each April alone and do not add much to their public sphere over the intervening year.

Some of this point scoring politics can be seen quite clearly in the current AV campaigns. For example the ‘No to AV’ programme points out costs that appear quite negligible in the long-term. It suggests millions will be spent on AV in explaining how it works – this should be common knowledge for us to make an informed decision BEFORE voting, not after it could become implemented policy. Also, discrediting the scheme through costs on new machines is hardly an acceptable argument – such machines would be useful under EITHER system of politics. However, more than these, the suggestion that there is excessive cost at having this referendum is rather insulting: democracy should be upheld at all costs; voices should not be ignored because of the ‘price’ of political freedom.

This is not to say that the ‘Yes’ voters have fared much better in their attempts at an independent campaign. It suggests that the AV system provides a bigger say in who comes first and last, and yet this phrase does not reflect the complexity of the vote count. In introducing this vote, there was a pledge it would help tackle what is commonly referred to as ‘seats for life’, but it will leave more than 200 seats unchanged. And surely the every vote counts argument is not unique to AV?

Increasingly, there appears cause for despair. Whilst politicians tackle each other with out of context quotes and front page jibes, the general public are left more unaware of the political ties. Although we have an impression of which party prefers whatever course of action relevant to a particular issue, there is little concrete argument as to why this conclusion has been reached: for both sides refer again and again to similar points.

In short, government is in need of reform and it is only achievable through the collaborative voices of the electorate ourselves. In seeking change, we seek politics to affect our daily lives for the better, for politics in action. No longer should these leaders of nations mock each other’s aims and sit passively by for a large proportion of the year. If only we exercise our own liberties, we could achieve such a more functioning government in many ways. No fully functioning government is given to us on a plate.

For more detailed insights to the flaws of the AV campaign, visit: http://thedolphinsblowhole.wordpress.com/2011/05/03/the-straw-man-referendum-how-the-av-debate-misses-the-point/