Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts

Friday, 9 November 2012

The Value of Work Experience

Originally written for The Guardian Comment is Free.


Another busy week is ending at The Guardian. A busy week which I've experienced first hand, taking up a placement opportunity at the newspaper. I've covered activist Malala, sleuthed James Bond's espionage hot spots, and been deluged with storm waves following Sandy on the live blog. But I'm not about to walk up to the news desk and demand a pay cheque for the week. When I leave the office this afternoon there will be no cash in hand for my hard work, but experience, the value of which is immeasurably greater.

Experience is a compulsory element of the graduate CV, even on a tight budget. Gone are the days when fresh faced University leavers could walk into an office with a smattering of A Levels and a role of paper from a Red Brick institute: education is no longer indicative of employment.

In the wake of the indiscretions of Blair's office, my friends and I soon found ourselves discussing the inevitability of unpaid experience as the only means by which to further our career prospects in a stormy recession. Rising youth unemployment and an increase in degree holders makes it almost impossible for companies to commit to contracts and long term employment without some proof of previous relevant work.

The almost universal problem in accessing this experience though transcends from the fact that a large proportion of the most established and reputable internships will be placed in London. I, like many of my friends, do not live in the capital. (Un)surprisingly, London just so happens to be expensive and out of many budgets. This fact severely limits and disables the options of many undergraduates searching for that big break. Yet talking with a friend who just started an internship in London last month, she said that “there was no alternative” to coming to the city, “no matter the cost”.

According to Intern Aware, not only are the majority of placements in London, where the cost of living is the highest in the UK, but The IPPR estimated in 2010 that there were around 100,000 unpaid internships in the UK. Of course, the problem is that unpaid internships are corrosive to social mobility and opportunity in a number of circumstances. If you cannot afford to support yourself for the period of the placement (fortunately for myself, this was achieved cheaply by bribing my aunt with some chocolate and leaving her a bottle of wine this morning), then there is little chance of substantial opportunity to further your horizons. Perhaps one placement is justifiable, but two or three consecutive stints of unpaid work leave students add a gaping hole to their already spiralling debt.

However, for my part, work experience is something that every student needs to acquire, regardless of wage. This is probably a divisive and contentious view, but let's be clear, I'm not one of these stereotyped students that can ring up mummy and daddy and ask for some money to be transferred so as I can enjoy London. My parents can't afford that additional expense, and frankly, nor do I expect to put that burden upon them. The student loan is also not the endless pot of Irish gold it appears to be in Freshers Week.

Yet, work experience and internships completed for free say a great deal more about the competency and dedication of the young employee. In a climate where companies continually bemoan the problem of telling applicants apart, those who have volunteered themselves to complete placements with minimal monetary support display a vivacity so essential to the work place (especially in the media).

Companies provide these placements to people entirely untrained, with little experience. Despite the brevity of the work, paid staff will have to take time out of their schedule to train, advise, guide the intern and is probably under constant supervision. Not to be condescending, but it's hardly realistic to expect to walk into The Guardian and land the front page whilst on placement.

Just as you pay for the service of university, work experience is something you pay for by making sacrifices of sorts. It's a privilege, not a right. Not that this statement should detract or act as an exoneration of Tony Blair's office. It's just, from the student outrage, you'd be forgiven for thinking this was a new problem.

Working for free is inherently integrated into the system of employment. I've covered some big issues this week for The Guardian: do I feel exploited? No: I feel privileged to be given this opportunity, to have some world renowned and respected journalists that lead their field have faith in me to turn out a piece suitable for publication.

Rewriting my CV this weekend, I'll be able to send out my portfolio with a massive boost to my prospective employers. For a short term inconvenience now, I stand to benefit enormously in the future. No one had really questioned this practice until now.

Perhaps a system in which work placements offer means-tested assistance, in a similar way to the student finance service, would proffer a much more accessible work place and encourage a larger number of students who believe their backgrounds hinder their progress to look into experience. I've hardly had to pay for anything this week, but it would be nice to go up to the news desk editor, bung a load of Oyster card receipts in his hand and get £30 back. For a student, that's a two-week food shop. My train fare would feed me until New Year's.

Unpaid internships may present themselves as social engineering in another format because of their obvious limitations, but they are social characterising. Hand in hand with the experience comes invaluable training and character building by observing the tough post-university world through a different, direct lens.

The comments of my friend in a London bar earlier this week strike a chord: “no alternative, no matter the cost.” If we expect employers to take young new employees seriously, we should first demonstrate our dedication to our crafts. The school of “something for nothing” is no longer a sustainable attitude for any graduate.

Tuesday, 25 October 2011

The Decline of University?: Applicants down 10%


Emerging statistics suggest that university applications for the forthcoming 2012-2013 academic calendar are down 10% on the number made for the previous year group.

Without hesitation, one is able to point blame at the impending introduction of the 9k fees, whose first term coincides with the prospective intake. The controversial decision to triple the amount universities are allowed to charge has seen an overwhelming number of institutions charges of the top level, despite promises that this would only be permitted in rare circumstances.

Of course, there was no method by which to implement an effective graded scale of pay across universities: as more money raised at any one institution elevates it significantly above its competitors in dispensable income and no faculty would want to suffer as a consequence.

Indeed, chair of the UCU lecturers’ union, Sally Hunt, advocated that “The government's fees policy has been a disaster from the start and it is clearly having a serious impact on the choices young people make.”

Levying the fees in such an unprecedented fashion makes a great many potential applicants look twice at 
their future prospects.

Consequently, the current trend of a 10% decrease in uptake can come as no real surprise, but an affirmation that the domain of academia could ocne again slowly become the reserve of the rich and priviledged.

Whilst deadlines for the vast majority of applications is not until January 2012, these early figures fo provide a forecasted outlook. UCAS admissions services monitors the activity and is set to give updates should there be any significant changes as have so far been seen.

Overall, there has been a 9% reduction in comparison to this time last year; but this figure adds a third when considering just UK students, with a 12% decrease at present.

Universities UK however has warned these are not necessarily the figures that will be seen come the New Year, since Oxbridge has witnessed only a 0.8% fall in hopeful students.

However, this could in fact be testament to the social demographic which chooses the elite pair amongst their five choices. Whilst the two oldest institutions have claimed to be making headway in ensuring equal accessibility opportunities over the past years, there is no doubt that this has caused a great deal of unrest with a number of staff, who have publically stated their grievances.

Could the small drop actually be reflective of the number of wealthier families that still plague the hallways of the revered grounds? Moreover, there is suggestion that since these numbers are not broken down for comparison of social area, there could indeed have been a reduction in state school hopefuls and a surge in private interest with the prospect of fewer places awarded to their mainstream counterparts.
A recent Guardian article review a similar issue and looked both at social economic and social ethnicity factors at Oxbridge.

As such, the discrepancy between Oxbridge figures and those on a nationwide level leave a great deal to ponder on.

Despite being against the rise in fees, this downturn in possible students gives rise to a number of unforeseen potential circumstances that may help in the long-run.

For example, in the midst of a global economic crisis, the streamlining of university functions is essential. In changing the number of students applying year on year, the colleges would be able to ensure lower costs and lower state dependencies, whilst producing graduates and continued research.

Furthermore, the job market is currently saturated with graduates who all boast a degree at a top ranking university in their field. Already, the worth and merit of study is deteriorating and ensuring that an undergraduate diploma is essentially of little consequence. To limit the number of persons who continually apply with such qualifications will allow a greater percentage of university leavers to find employ in their chosen area (should the financial troubles subside and growth resume).

In addition, many who would have gone to university simply because their friends, relatives or pets were applying will now reconsider. Perhaps this will give a boost to apprenticeships and skilled trades who often lost out to the luring prospects of University. Perhaps this will see a unique boom in industry that, if sustained correctly, would produce economic benefits.

This is not to campaign for or provide a late exoneration of the government policy however. Restricting the paths of a number of citizens is quite potentially the equivalent of a 21st century disenfranchisement. Abusing students as a scapegoat for market difficulties only emphasises the moral bankruptcy of the government in addition to their financial bankruptcy.

Come January, a clearer picture of numbers and their heritages will emerge: but until then, the dream of graduation appears slimmer for a large number, who will have to consider alternative outlets, while oppressed by high inflation, stagnant job opportunities and now elitist education academies.


Wednesday, 1 June 2011

The True Value of the Student.


One may assume that the economy and education have little in common: on the surface, the first is a matter of national wealth affecting all areas of population life, while the latter is the trivial concern of youngsters.  Whilst the economy is a consistent worry of the majority, education is a problematic feature that many ignore.

However, whilst the economy shrunk, university intake continued its seemingly exponential increase in applicants. The popularity of the universities, still surrounded by a plethora of promises for better employment prospects and lessons in life, led to an increasingly diverse pool of peoples who could systematically be exploited to support the failing economy. The two spheres thus became irrevocably intertwined last year amidst a contentious bill to increase the student fees to 9k. 

Due to the level of controversy over the cuts, it was somewhat impossible to be ignorant of the demonstrations and protests that were organised nationwide and specifically in London. As images of defaced monuments and attacked royal cars emerged, there was a great social disapproval of what appeared an unruly group. Contrary to depicting the injustice of government proposals, the unfolding occurrences marred support. 

As the measures come into force then, many questions are unresolved. How will the student be able to adjust to such a staggering increase in cost? How will this ensure education is available to all those who wish to pursue it? Will this not impinge upon University expansion and research?

Nine thousand pounds per annum makes Britain’s university systems one of the most expensive around the globe. In fact, the changes come as Britain has begun a decline down the tables of World University ratings. As such, there could be argument that the increases ensure that one is paying more for an inferior service. There is no other industry where such a correlation between price and provision would be openly tolerated.

Part of the problem is that students have been afforded an image that only breeds discontent and impassivity from important members of the social circle by consequence of the actions of a minority. However, in the economic recovery, we are expected to reimburse the state with an enormous sum after graduation. This is in addition to the fact that our active participation in University generates sufficient amounts of income for the state via research output and the involvement in the local community. These are not exhaustive examples by any means. Furthermore, students support the teaching profession itself and by consequence of further education output, there are more qualified peoples to ensure expansion of diverse enterprises. Thus the student already provides a key crux in economic stability without having to carry token burdens. 

“Governments want to use universities to upgrade their workforce and develop hi-tech industries” says Philip Altbach, director of the Centre for International Higher Education Universities, proving that the government has just as much invested in the success of the University scheme as the students themselves. He reaffirms that “in the rich countries, Universities are making big bucks”. This is something that is readdressed by the UK's universities minister, David Willetts, who continued to advocate that "developed economies are already highly dependent on universities and if anything that reliance will increase.” We should focus on the word ‘dependent’ here. How should this dependency rise?

Recently, a BBC article suggested that the way in which we judged a country’s power and influence was under a flux of change. Whilst one hundred years ago, it may have been Empire, two hundred past it would have been developing industrialisation, it is now fast becoming the student themselves. Hardly surprising, the student is the centre of research activity, of professional output, of cultural change. In undertaking degrees in what has become a globalised scheme, the adults are able to gain knowledge, experience new influences and take note of other world systems that all mix together in a melting pot to fuel social revolution. Consequently, the student is at the forefront of discovery, of modern social mobility and continued economic growth.

‘Dependant’ as a term to describe the economy in relation to the student is quite a powerful chip to possess. To say that the county and the world as a whole is largely dependent on the student domain is to infer that the untapped potential of the teenage sphere could create a great tumult if it were to approach the fee changes in a much more cerebral manner.

Considering the level of support the student already provides, imagine the extent of potential damage should the demand for education dry up in response to the unnecessary exploitation of this social group. Hypothetically, if students for 2012 entry were to withdraw applications so that the university system collapsed, a viable market would be closed. For these students who would sacrifice their education, no doubt will there be great unease. However, with fewer graduates, employers would face no other alternative than to encourage these youngsters into the workplace to compensate for demand. If they refused, economic decline would only further ensue.

The result of such defiance? With a reduced market, the government not only has lost valuable income, but the reputation of English research would be put in jeopardy. Through this, the student will have proven their integral part of the economic recovery without having coloured people against their plight. Government officials would be obliged to reconsider their unjustified increase in fees in order to sustain economic recovery.

Currently, it is estimated that LSE spends about £0.5billion each year. Oxbridge is said to be slightly more, top Russell group establishments slightly less. This is only the disposable income of each institution: they actually sit upon funds much more numerous than that. Just more than 480,000 students are expected to start as freshers in the academic calendar 2011/2012. If we take this figure for the following year, the first year students alone would provide £4,320,000,000 in tuition fees alone. Imagine that figure trebled in three years. By no means can this be justified. Withdrawing our applications would see hundreds of billions of pounds stop circulating – from the education department, to local businesses, to research output. Stagnating such a gross figure would cut deep into the spending plans of government and reveal the true potential of the student class.

Combined pressures from exams, loans and often job burdens have seen students addressed as one of the most vulnerable groups in society. It is concerning that the government should therefore only add to the inevitable woe of the scholars in order to achieve a quicker, more haphazard, recovery. Students should be encouraged of a much more drastic approach in order to have their opinion counted: if the country is to withhold status on an international scale, the value of its (under)graduates should not be undermined or doubted to any extent. 

More general information on the globalisation of universities and generated wealth can be read here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-12597811