Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts
Showing posts with label religion. Show all posts

Sunday, 2 December 2012

The 11th Commandment


Recently, the Church of England opposed a movement to allow women to become bishops within their religious community. With the failure to accept this modern move, the church only makes itself even more seemingly outdated and outmoded precursor to 21st century living.

The proposal, rejected on the 20th November, refused the ordination of women bishops largely on the grounds of tradition. However, in an era where tradition is often disregarded for the latest in innovation, and equality is always at the forefront of Western democracy, this argument does not appeal to the public en masse.

Perhaps you might cry that this in itself is blasphemy and indicative of how far Western civilization has moved away from religious doctrine.

Yet, religion is, by its definition, a system of personal beliefs (“The belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, esp. a personal God”). If we are to galvanise a generation to return to God, then we need build out from the belief that God is all understanding, all knowing and all forgiving.

Surely, this God in all his wisdom would not allow for women bishops if he thought it sacrilege. You may deem that statement something akin to a religious nut. But the inverse argument is being upheld in practice. God has not given a sign, so let’s not move forward.

A Christ-like prophet today would surely amend a great many of the practical sides of the Christian doctrine. The fundamentals would of course be the same: but, restrictive and outdated views, informed by gender, orientation, race and other discriminatory factors would be all but removed.

The ‘example’ of Christ who had 12 male disciples is often used as a staunch argument for preventing women entering these positions in the church. However, Jesus, an outsider in the message he preached, needed male figures to continue to carry his message if it were to last and survive. Women of the 1st century, through to women of the 20th century, hardly held social influence at large. Women weren’t sidelined, just fulfilled roles that social positioning would allow them.

Now, social equality means that stigmas attached to the fairer sex are not at all restrictive. Why would religion keep up this pretence.

More, can someone please explain this decision with any rationale when a Queen can be supreme dictator (or whatever the official term actually is) of the Church of England, and well, the same one has been for the past 60 years. There is no logic. At all.

Besides, if we’re all wrong about this equality for all (which from just about every teaching ever, I’d say we’re not), our all merciful God will forgive us, because the omnipresent being will comprehend that we did it with the best of intentions.

All that has been achieved is a further zone of religious exclusion. And if anything, surely that is the larger of these two sins by any measurement.

Thursday, 3 May 2012

Religious Misunderstandings and the Case of Cardinal Sean Brady


Religion is increasingly seen as outdated, outmoded and outranked by twenty-first century dilemmas such as politics, economics and the trivial but trendy fashion scenes. In fact, despite being classed a Catholic country, it gradually appears that we are perhaps more catholic in culture than by practice.

We distance ourselves from religion, which seems logical given that these organisations once proffering hope feature in our lives more and more through media stories, and negative media stories at that.

Whether it’s an anti-gay movement, or a slur on Islam, the religion crisis continuously rears its head and is so often something that twenty-first century paraphernalia attempts to shield us from.

Take, for example, the current case of Cardinal Brady, wrapped amidst a certain fervour concerning a, somewhat archetypal news piece, of paedophilia within the church.

On Tuesday, a BBC documentary revealed that in 1975, a 14-year-old boy who had been sexually abused by a paedophile priest, Fr Brendan Smyth, gave the then Fr Brady the names of other children who had been abused.

The scandal however is focussed on the fact that the Father did not then proceed to inform either parents or relevant police officials about the information that had been divulged to him.

Yet, whilst many people have suddenly jumped on the bandwagon, so to speak, in support of the Cardinal’s removal, that quick logic ignores cornerstone doctrine of the church itself that has been respected for centuries.
The idea that most probably held the Father’s tongue was that sanctity of confession, where the priest is not allowed to repeat, by oath, anything which he has been told over the course of the religious practice.

It is a fairly obstinate routine for twenty-first century officials, but it has well served various people across the millennia as a source of forgiveness and secrecy. Since it is not clear whether this confused teenager was more confused rather than angry, there is a problematic situation in deciding how far the priest is guilty of any wrong-doing.

This is not necessarily to read as an exoneration: from my perspective, the priest should have acted to protect those of his parish. However, it highlights that perhaps the now cardinal has risen to his current position by always practicing the letter of religious teachings. His mediation of his role has been taken extremely seriously and in fact he could consider that repeating something spoken in confidence would in fact injure his religious duties.

Different ideals between religion and other aspects of society are frequent cause for divide then, and there are calls for reformation of practice. Yet, it is interesting that this year marks the fiftieth anniversary of the inauguration of the Second Vatican Council which made profound reforms in the Church. The Roman Catholic mind-set is one in which admissions and revisions have been granted for this age of society, even if others think it needs to go further.

Whilst the 2001 census found more than 71% of people in the UK to deem themselves Catholic, a Guardian/ICM pollin 2006 found that just 33% describe themselves as "a religious person" while 82% see religion as a cause of division and tension between people. The Ipsos MORI poll in 2003 reported that only 18% were "a practising member of an organised religion".

Marred by a crisis of faith and a constant string of negative images from child abuse to supporting social inequalities, the Catholic church, and particularly the Roman Catholic church, has to come a considerable way towards twenty-first century life if it is to spark a revival and capture the imaginations of the majority.

To read more about various perspectives on the Cardinal’s position, see this BBC news report.