Showing posts with label markets. Show all posts
Showing posts with label markets. Show all posts

Thursday, 26 January 2012

Flower of Scotland


1916: In the middle of World War One, Ireland stages a bid for independence in Dublin, threatening the British chances of success at a crucial moment in the war effort.

2012: In the middle of the worst recession since the Wall Street Crash, Scotland stages a democratic bid for independence “in Edinburgh, in London, or anywhere the Prime Minister pleases”, with many deeming the act detrimental to British growth at a crucial moment of European downgrading.

Certainly, the debate waging around the possibility of independence versus unity has seen battle lines drawn, but these may be premature concerns.

Previous breakups of the United Kingdom in Ireland provide a primary cause for concern. However, the eventual independence granted to Ireland was more an appeasement following a costly war, with transition handled distastefully by both parties. Looking back over the course and administration of the change of power, there are easily identifiable mistakes that could (and should) be avoided in the case of Scottish independence.

Continued violence and hostility is the true legacy of Irish independence and that was a threat suffered particularly till the turn of the century, but a decade ago. Scottish independence, on the other hand, would be entered into through democratic debate rather than the forceful mode of conduct that kickstarted and marked the Irish movement. England, not as prominent on a world scene, would be more amenable to these discussions than its own rash nature almost 100 years ago, when maintaining status was a priority.

Besides, a peaceful resolution would be encouraged while resources are stretched so thin across the United Kingdom due to cuts.

However, Scotland would surely earn the lion’s share of these resources from a split. Economically vibrant at the moment, Scotland has, as expected, the second largest GVA per capita in the United Kingdom, after England. Yet, many do not appreciate, or are completely unaware of, the fact that revenue from the North Sea oil rigs are not included in these figures, as the profit is currently ‘distributed’ around the UK instantly. With independence, 91% of the oil area lies within the Scottish borders. The sudden wealth that would be available to the northern territory as a whole would transform many areas of public spending and investment: leaving Scotland with little deficit.

In fact, it is already recognised that Scotland is the largest producer of petroleum within the EU, and that there is potential for other offshore oil-sites.

Additionally, Scotland is the central zeitgeist for whiskey lovers worldwide. Exports in specialisms such as whiskey, shortbreads, fudges and fishing produce earn the Scottish country a reputation for delicacies renowned the world over. Add the prominence in manufacturing and construction (Glasgow for example houses the largest shipping construction area within the UK), and one can see the advantages to a booming Scottish economy.

Already a relatively rich nation, the boost proffered from continued exports would ensure gained capital and circulation of the pound. In 2007 alone, Scotland’s top 10 export destinations alone earned the country in excess of £18,825 million. Imagine the growth in this figure with Scottish independence, backed peacefully by England.

In turn, this could help Scotland to tackle its slums and poverty problems. Despite the economic benefits of the oil, there is still marked difference between lifestyles of many Scots and their counterparts south of the border. An average male in Glasgow for example only has a life expectancy of 69. Scottish public services see themselves as inhabiting a different social area than England and Wales, with different key issues of poverty, drugs, and unemployment to tackle.

However, even with the separation, use of the GBP will insure continued intrinsic links with the remaining UK factions. Extra trade on the pound from Scotland will ensure continued circulation that benefits England and Wales itself in the long run.

A poll by YouGov last May showed marginal support for the move, but an overwhelming rejection from Scotland itself.

Perhaps the break-away of Scotland would also encourage a deeper look at the British image: a modern twenty-first century conglomerate of cultures hinged on London. The investment seen across Scotland should be mimicked across larger areas of the UK. HS2 makes some steps in that direction, but relatively few and relatively slowly. England is not capitalising upon its current market opportunities. Expanse of infrastructure would allow greater migration of peoples across the country for jobs. Focussing our main sources of income on development would allow a certain independence in a time of Eurozone uncertainty, creating a more stable market area.  A galvanised population to the North could teach English people a thing or two about national pride for sure.

Scuppering Salmond’s hopes for Scotland however are the Welsh and Irish members of Parliament, claiming that Scottish dominion in its own right would leave the two areas outvoiced within Westminster.

Nonetheless, considering moves towards Welsh parliaments, it would appear rather foolhardy to prevent progress for the sake of tradition. Not only does the move allow England a greater democratic voice, but it is not in the apocalyptic fashion that the Welsh and Irish describe: rather radicalisation on both sides of the border due to the split would see new ideas emerge as to how the country should be run and here lies the prospect of wide social and cultural change (the thing the Welsh and Irish appear to advocate amidst a Tory government).

With no date currently set for the vote (despite furious debate over timing this past week), we shall have to watch the development and resolution of lingering issues, such as currency, military, and Nuclear warheads over the coming months.

Shaking of the shackles of union is never an easy transition, but for the cultural, economic and social benefits that Scotland could wager, perhaps the UK should be more amenable to the shouts of “FREEDOM”.

Tuesday, 24 January 2012

Downgraded European Economies is a Punishment for Germany.


As the Eiffel Tower sits overlooking the Seine in the centre of Europe’s capital of love, it appears that Standard and Poor, the international credit rating agency, have fallen out of love with the French capital.  

Downgrading of nine European Union economies last week did not come as a surprise, per se, but remained a bitter blow, especially to the second largest Eurozone economy. Rating changes for nine countries highlights the need for new austerity measures, before introducing growth plans.

Perhaps this is the reason Britain remains unchanged in S&P’s poll: Cameron’s government moved quickly to introduce cuts and the fact that these measures have been undertaken without direction has been rewarded from the worldwide monetary agency.

Without doubt, Britain’s position is far from safe: while the short term consequences see a gain in GBP strength and trade prospects on an international scale, the intrinsically linked economies of Europe are a fragile set of dominos. A single collapse at this stage of the crisis could prove the kindling for an explosive series of economic shortcomings and bailouts.

Indeed, plans introduced to cancel 70% of Greece’s debt last Friday are but moves to buy time for the Euro and all related economies.

Whilst it is believed the move may help Greece to start to implement new means of recovery that will slowly abate the spread of financial interdependence, the wiping of such an astronomical figure from the central funds of Europe is equivalent to pulling the plug on a vast resource of wealth. With fewer countries classified AAA, the missing money could prove to be nigh on impossible to replace, meaning that it would undermine the significant advances made in industry over 2011.

Should such an econopocalyptic event pass, it is likely to trigger debt that cannot be undone within our lifetimes.

France’s image as one half of the economic megaforce upholding the Eurozone has now been shattered. Sarkozy’s right to stand on a podium alongside Merkel has been removed: former foes had been presenting a united front as the 17 countries that use the euro face their biggest crisis since World War II. Now, whilst a blow for the president, concerns should shift from where France went wrong to where Germany now finds itself.

Economically, Germany is on the precipice before the abyss. All of Europe looks to its €211 billion ($267.32 billion) contribution to the Eurozone rescue fund as a source of saviour. Although Luxembourg, Finland and the Netherlands all maintain their AAA rating in addition to Germany, the mother of the Rhineland is able to boast a donation to the Eurofund that is more than treble that of the other three combined.

Germany is once again isolated in the centre of countries that threaten it: no longer the supposed threat of invasion, but the threat of siphoning all the funds possible for ulterior economic issues.

Relative strengths and weaknesses of key economies have been realigned by the changes and Germany becomes more vulnerable to credit crisis the more that its own funds are charged with the duty not only of small periphery nations, such as Greece and Portugal, but large central blocs, as France and Italy.

Any increase in bailout costs comes from German pockets and this appears to be something that the German electorate may not bear with merely a customary grumble too much longer. This could lead to potential referendums on the amount Germany puts into the fund, or even on the Euro itself.

However, the cost of breaking up the Eurozone itself could be catastrophic as billions of Euros are lost in every area from trade to administration and all problems in between. In fact, the relative weakness of the surrounding economies at least makes German products more competitive, which means Berlin earns more capital.

All the same, the opinion of the voter would depend on the projection of their outlook. Germany, likely to reassert itself as the strongest economy before European counterparts could still see benefits from a break in the single unit currency within a decade or two. Markets would always seek the hub of enterprise and exports offered by the central state.

The risks of both cases are, unfortunately, war. Ironically, the Franco-German alliance now enters a turbulent stage wherein the two countries sit on the crux of imposing a disaster on the rest of the economy, continent and world.

Should Germany continue to support its Eurozone counterparts, there may emerge a sentiment of anger and resentment that would see a war break out due to a lack of appeasement. On the other hand, if Germany were to break its ties, it could grow strong amidst a state of turmoil and seek further expansion in order to capitalise on new found economic prospects. And who could say that such a route would be devastating – the application of German stratagems could provide economic balance further than its current boundaries. Or should Germany leave, other European countries may feel abandoned and declare action as a last ditch effort to prove their own flailing might in the face of German capitalist gains.

After all, one of the main contributing factors of the Second World War was the sheer amount of economic wealth that was drained from Germany by other European countries. But then, when have we ever learnt from history?

Sparkling over the night waters of the Seine, the Eiffel Tower appears an oversized, abandoned Christmas decoration, spreading little warmth to the heart of Paris, threatening to be washed away by the tide of debt on which it is founded.

Sunday, 30 October 2011

Europe Rising.


Standing in the Commons on Monday, Prime Minster David Cameron was heckled and faced his largest opposition to date: however, these criticisms came largely not from the opposite bench, but from those sat behind him.

Debates regarding the British membership in the EU remain fierce and frantic. Online polls from various websites largely concur that the British public feel it necessary to call a referendum on the issue of European Union membership and there is evidence that large swaths of the voting public are interested in a renegotiation of the terms of membership at the very least.

The backbench motion was defeated by 483 votes to 111.

Cameron and the vast majority of Parliament officials voted against the reformation, after all Tory, Lib Dem and Labour MPs had been instructed to oppose it.

However, that is far from helping define the gravity of the issue.

Proposed by a Conservative MP, David Nutall, the motion was brought forward under the insistence that the vast majority of those eligible to vote had not had their say on the EU. And he said the UK Parliament was becoming "ever more impotent" as the "tentacles" of the European Union "intruded into more and more areas of national life".


Of course, no government can ever assume to be possessed of the right of power over an issue to the end of time. In an almost repetitious manner, the government here are setting up a power by assumption; they appear to cling to laws that are inherited as definitive of the current time.

As the circumstances of the world are constantly changing and we live through a rather volatile and unstable set of political movements, an act of non-repeal is taken for consent on certain issues, presumably to ensure some social stability. Voicing the need for change is the first step.

Yet in the face of this adversity, the Conservative party imposed a three-line whip on backbench motion on their representatives. In short, any that voted in favour of the bill and against the Tory grain were to be forced to leave their posts.

Such almost childish quibbles should not be the resort of a government not only criticised as fragile, but who are managing a country through one of the most difficult financial negotiations of human history. In fact, it ensures Mr Cameron and co have more a look of a totalitarian state: ignoring public feel and punishing those MPs, whose job it is to serve their community – ergo, punishing public opinion.

Whilst I do not consider an exit from Europe a viable move for the UK considering the globalisation of markets and trade, the methods executed to prevent such an event are hindering progression in the main.

Asked whether he regretted the order, Mr Cameron argued, "No I don't: in politics you have to try to confront the big issues, rather than try to sweep them under the carpet and that's what we did yesterday.”

All the same, this appears a rather dubious comment. Considering that his party has a history of infamous relationships and opinions on Europe (looking back to the Thatcher era), this defence could be seen as unique. It is arguable that Cameron is sweeping an issue under the rug in his hard line of action. Instead of allowing an open debate on the issue and gaining an accurate image of the concerns, there has been elected to power a leader whose prerogative on this issue seems against free speech.

Although the current timing may not suit, the motion would certainly give an idea of policies that should be considered for future governments.

Eurosceptics and members of the Conservative party alike remain somewhat bemused by the events of the past week however. Cameron’s public stance since coming to power has been one of a firm hand with Europe: proclaiming efforts to take back powers from Brussels, this was not the dedication many had hoped for last May.

Perhaps these restrictions are more indicative of a wartime government, for we should be under no illusions that the current stand point is that we are in a war on debt. On a global scale.

“Every step closer to the exit sign shakes confidence in the British economy and can hit British jobs.” argued Nick Clegg after the votes had been announced and there is no doubt a truth in his proclamation. With downgrading already occurring and forecasts being realigned, not even the onset of the 2012 Olympic games seems to be aiding a boost to our economy.

Reforms that are still primary concerns are said to be on the agenda still, but approached in much more a softly, softly manner, as Clegg added that “You reform Europe by leading it.”

Nonetheless, with a plethora of problems melting in the mixing point, the next decade will be one that continues to produce turbulence across Europe. Angela Merkel, the Chancellor of Germany, earlier this week predicted the threatening results of a collapse of the Euro: “let us be under no illusion, another decade of peace in Europe cannot be an absolute certainty.” she proclaimed to large scoffs.

Extreme or rational? The idea plays on a great many fundamental truths; if European nations do not pull together over the current climate of Euro debt, then markets and trade suffer, amidst increasing demands for consumer items and supplies in an ever growing world. Add to this countries pulling every which way to suit their own political aim and not that of the majority, then there quickly establishes a tentative web of allegiances and political oppositions that mirrors the outbreak of World War One just a century later. 

Merkel’s comments certainly make for interesting outlooks and should not be skated around.

Cameron need reacquaint himself with public interest: his rash action is certainly done in the best interest to economic growth, but forcing a wedge between parliament and the public is one certain way to have an overspill of riots: and considering continued activism at St Pauls, planned strikes at the end of November and continued student demos from the end of last year, the Conservative party is not one with many activist friends. Now, it alienates its own members in the largest uprising in modern Tory history.